In a small business, juggling the multiple daily tasks thrown your way can already become overwhelming quickly. Whether it’s accounting or HR, you can become stretched thin trying to manage diverse responsibilities with limited resources and staff. And that’s without factoring in sick leave.
Because the reality is, especially in smaller businesses, these responsibilities become even more challenging when unexpected sick leave crops up—and even more costly if you need to hire temporary cover or pay your people overtime to plug the gaps. To help reduce strain on your business (both financially and mentally for your teams), it’s important to have the correct procedures in place to facilitate an employee’s return to work. And we have just the thing.
We’ll cover all you need to know about successfully managing employee return from sick leave to be supportive, organised, and compliant with HR laws.
The challenges for small businesses when managing employee sickness
According to figures from CIPD, the sickness absence rate in the UK is 62% higher than pre-pandemic levels, which is a serious concern for employers and the government. However, for small business managers in particular, the impact of a high sickness absence rate is considerable. Think reduced productivity, added strain on resources, and increased workloads for the rest of your team.
High staff sickness levels, or cases of excessive absenteeism, can lower morale among remaining team members, decreasing motivation and overall job satisfaction. This doesn’t just impact productivity through extended project deadlines, but also in the retention of your current team as they take on extra responsibilities to keep everything running smoothly.
Considering that seven in 10 (69%) workers state that their workload is far too much and negatively impacts their mental health—compared with only 14% of those who say their workload is about right—it’s vital that you have the correct procedures in place to manage workloads in periods of absence.
Navigating employee return from sick leave opens many opportunities for small businesses to prioritise the health and satisfaction of their employees, leading to better productivity and success in meeting targets. With careful consideration, you can find a balance between offering employee support when on sick leave and when they return–all while staying compliant with HR laws. Sounds good, right?
Get the latest HR updates, straight to your inbox
Get the latest HR insights and best practice guides, direct to your inbox.
The do’s and don’ts of managing employee return from sick leave
So, what should you be doing—or more importantly, not doing—when it comes to managing employee return from sick leave? Let’s have a look through some do’s and don’ts to make sure you’re employees feel supported through their illness and your operations stay as uninterrupted as possible:
Do
1. Offer flexible sick leave policies
No two illnesses are the same. A strong sick leave policy needs enough flexibility to reflect different conditions, recovery times, and pressures—without adding stress when someone is already unwell.
That includes recognising mental health as well as physical health. Many organisations now include mental health days within their sickness absence policy, which works well when expectations are clear and applied consistently.
2. Provide clear guidelines
Give every employee clear procedures for reporting and documenting sick leave, especially for remote and hybrid employees needing regular in-person interactions with their line manager. This should cover things like:
- Eligibility: who is eligible for sick leave, for example, full-time and part-time team members eligibility may differ from probationary employees.
- Use: how sick leave is actually used, including details of who to contact (and when) as well as what systems to use to log the period of absence and add any supporting documents.
- Paid leave: include if your policy covers paid leave like statutory sick pay, unpaid leave, or a mix of the two.
- Medical evidence: as evidence is needed in sick leave that lasts 7 days or more, make this clear in your policy, covering where they can obtain it and when they will need to get a sick note.
- Support: make it clear what support you have in place for your people as they navigate their time off work and their return, too.
This should also extend to their return to workplace, with any return to work documentation (like return forms or action plans) set into motion as soon as possible.
3. Lead by example
People notice what leaders do. If you follow the same absence management procedures you expect from your teams, it reinforces fairness and trust.
Consistency matters here. When managers model the right behaviour, policies feel real rather than theoretical. So You should practice what you preach, after all!
4. Provide resources and assistance
Returning to work can feel daunting. Offering practical support—such as help with medical paperwork or access to employee assistance programmes—can make a big difference.
This works especially well when support is tailored to the person and their circumstances, not just a generic tick-box activity.
5. Check in regularly
Managing sickness absence is not a case of out of sight, out of mind. Regular check-ins help you understand how someone is recovering and whether adjustments are still needed.
Even a short, supportive conversation can reassure someone that they are valued—not pressured.
6. Provide ongoing training to line managers
Well-trained managers can support your people in their recovery. Poorly trained ones can do the opposite.
Make sure managers understand how to handle absence sensitively, legally, and consistently—especially when balancing empathy with operational needs.
7. Keep accurate records
Not only does having accurate and up-to-date employee absence records allow you to manage sick leave successfully, but it can also help identify any patterns that may require intervention.
Good record-keeping will help spot trends and patterns in sick leave and address potential issues proactively, such as identifying departments or teams experiencing higher sickness rates to improve employee well-being and reduce absenteeism.
With Cintra People, you can schedule regular reports to be generated automatically, choosing the timing that works best for your small business.
Don't
1. Assume that all sick leave requests are dishonest or unnecessary
Don’t discourage staff members from taking necessary time off when genuinely unwell. After all, questioning motives damages trust, making people feel judged for being unwell. This can lead to further health complications, spread of illness to other colleagues, and decreased productivity.
Encourage a trusting work environment by showing empathy when team members ask for sick leave. A culture of trust works better than suspicion.
2. Rush employees back to work before they are ready
Bringing someone back too soon often backfires—for them and for your business. Their recovery can take longer, and the risk of further absence increases.
For example, expecting full duties immediately after an injury—without phased adjustments—can lead to re-injury and lead to more time needed. It’s important to make the necessary changes to accommodate your people, whether it’s reduced hours, allowing them to work remote if necessary, or even making reasonable adjustments to their workspace.
3. Share confidential medical information without explicit consent
Disclosing personal and sensitive employee information harms trust and affects morale. It may also lead to legal action for breaking privacy laws, resulting in financial penalties and damage to your reputation.
So, it’s vital to keep all of your employee information confidential and secure. And a HR management software is a great way to do this, making sure that all information is kept safely and accessible to the right people only.
4. Discriminate against employees based on their health condition or history of sick leave
Don’t treat employees unfairly because of their illness or time off. For instance, excluding employees from team events or social gatherings because they’ve been sick can make people feel left out and unfairly treated, leading to direct discrimination and creating feelings of isolation and hurt among employees.
5. Overlook the impact of mental health issues
Ignoring mental health issues can create stigma and unfair treatment at work, making the workplace unwelcoming for those affected. Don’t overlook the impact of mental health on sick leave and future wellness.
Provide mental health training to all employees to raise awareness and increase understanding of conditions such as depression and anxiety. It’s also encouraged to invite open discussions about the impact of mental health on sickness absence in team meetings or company-wide forums so everyone has a shared understanding of the signs and how to support colleagues.
6. Fail to comply with legal requirements
HR legislation such as the Equality Act and Statutory Sick Pay Regulations mandates that employees have certain rights regarding sick leave and returning to work after illness.
Compliance with legal requirements avoids employee stress, potential legal disputes, and financial penalties.
Manage sick leave with confidence with Cintra
Sick leave is an inevitability so having the measures in place to manage it is a fundamental for any business, especially smaller ones. With Cintra People, we have everything you need to manage employee sick leave with confidence, from employee self service to allow your people to provide the information you need to automated processes to make the return to work simple.
Book a demo to see how you can support your employees’ well-being, maintain productivity levels, and maintain a healthy work culture with Cintra People.
Cintra People HR Software
HR software that brings HRIS, payroll, performance, and engagement together—helping you see what’s really happening in your workforce, solve challenges quickly, and make work better for everyone.
An employee can return from sick leave early, as long as they are fit enough to do so and it doesn’t impact their wellbeing. You should make sure that they will not be risking their health by return before their sick note ends and consider any reasonable adjustments needed to facilitate their return.
Reasonable adjustments are changes you can make the return to work easier on your people. These will be specific to each person and their circumstances and can cover mental or physical health issues. This covers finding a new way to do something to make it accessible to everyone, making changes to your workplace, changing someone’s working arrangements, or providing additional equipment or support.
Yes, you can contact employees while they are on sick leave; in fact, it’s encouraged to check on their wellbeing and offer any support. By law, you must also keep employees up to date regarding things like redundancies, reorganisations, or other job opportunities. It should be mutually agreed how often the contact should be and how the contact should take place (for example, by phone or email).
